reiko

kung fu fighting....the evolution of the art form....

Comments

Oh, alright. The postings.

This posting Hong Kong Films since July 1, 1997 Part 2 shows the 1990's top films in HK compared to the Western releases in Hong Kong in box office.

This posting Is Box Office Everything is my regular tracking of how Asian movies are doing overseas. It's continuously being updated.

I'm a numbers person but as I say in my posting, box office is not everything. It may be to the untrained eye, the non-Chinese, the film investors, but as to whether a film is good or not, seasoned Chinese film viewers will tell you many of the top box office are not good enough.

Rotten Tomatoes reviewers are very different from a Chinese viewer's opinion. Let me tell you why.

crouching tiger TOMATOMETER: 97

hero: TOMATOMETER: 95

kung fu hustle: TOMATOMETER: 90

hofd: TOMATOMETER 88

kill bill TOMATOMETER 85

Crouching Tiger was a failure in Asia because what it showed was nothing spectacular. Every martial art movie has those Ching Siu Tung moves before and so Asians refused to watch it. But it was new for the US.

Hero is hated by many Chinese because it is a political propaganda piece (around the world - mainlanders of course stay quiet on such issues) telling the world how good it is that the country got unified under one emperor - an emperoro who was pretty ruthless. Mainland Chinese laughed at the HK Mandarin accents of the actors, HK people laughed at the dance steps and ballet style of the fight. It's not a real martial art movie per se but hey, the non-Chinese likes it. Two years delay for releasing in the US is a joke. By then many have watched the DVD.

Kung Fu Hustle should have a higher rating than any of the above because Stephen Chow created this movie for not only HK public, but fit for the world with enough bloodshed to satisfy Asian viewers. Unfortunately, it had PG 13 because of violence or it could have been more successful. It incorporates traditional Chinese martial arts with contemporary approach and it's outstanding.

HOFD is a piece of crap. So is Kill Bill. They should get 50 if anything.

Post a comment

Already a Vox member? Sign in

Advertisement

  • Powered by Vox